1 Mar at 7:10 am

10 Metrics To Track A/B Testing Success

Want to improve your A/B testing results? Start by tracking these 10 key metrics.

A/B testing helps you optimize your website or marketing campaigns, but success depends on measuring the right data. Here’s a quick overview of the most important metrics to monitor:

Conversion Rate: The percentage of visitors completing your desired action (e.g., purchases, sign-ups).
Click-Through Rate (CTR): How many users click on a specific element compared to impressions.
Bounce Rate: The percentage of visitors leaving after viewing just one page.
Time on Page: How long users stay on a specific page.
Revenue per Visit (RPV): The average revenue generated per website visitor.
Average Order Value (AOV): The average amount spent per transaction.
Customer Lifetime Value (CLV): The total revenue a customer generates over their lifetime.
Form Completion Rate: The percentage of users who complete and submit forms.
Page Load Speed: Faster load times improve user experience and conversion rates.
User Navigation Patterns: Insights into how users move through your site.

Why These Metrics Matter

Each metric provides unique insights into user behavior, helping you refine your tests and improve outcomes. For example, higher CTRs may not always lead to better conversions unless paired with low bounce rates and high time on page.

By combining these metrics, you can identify what works, fix what’s broken, and drive meaningful results for your business.

3 Types of A/B Testing Metrics

1. Conversion Rate

Conversion rate measures the percentage of visitors who take a specific action, calculated as: (Conversions ÷ Total Visitors) x 100 . In 2023, the average conversion rate across industries was 2.9%, with landing pages performing much better at 23% .

This metric is essential for making informed decisions. As Chinmay Daflapurkar, Digital Marketing Associate at Arista Systems, explains:

"Connecting your goals and project guarantees you consistently choose KPIs that make a real difference. It’s important to consider the availability and reliability of data. Some metrics may be easier to track and measure than others or may be more prone to fluctuations or inaccuracies. It’s important to choose metrics that can be consistently tracked and measured over time to ensure the validity of the KPIs."

Examples of Success

True Botanicals used social proof to generate over $2M in ROI and achieved a 4.9% site-wide conversion rate .
Bombas boosted logins by 36% and increased orders by 4.1% simply by switching from an icon to a text-based call-to-action (CTA) .

Effective Tactics That Drive Conversions

Social Proof: Adding reviews or testimonials can influence buyers, as nine out of ten shoppers read reviews before purchasing .
Mobile Optimization: DocuSign simplified their mobile sign-up process and saw a 35% increase in mobile conversions .
Personalization: Tailored content helped Visa achieve 20% higher conversion rates, aligning with research showing personalized strategies are 41% more effective .

Analyzing conversion data by user behavior or demographics can help identify problem areas and ensure changes resonate with your audience .

2. Click-Through Rate (CTR)

Click-through rate (CTR) measures how many users click on a specific element compared to the number of times it’s seen. It’s calculated as: (Clicks ÷ Impressions) x 100 . CTR is a key metric for assessing how well your content encourages user interaction during A/B testing.

Industry Benchmarks

Knowing the average CTRs across different channels helps set realistic expectations for your tests :

Channel	Average CTR
Social Media	1.2%
Google Ads	3–5%
Email Campaigns	2.91%

In most cases, hitting a 2% CTR is seen as a strong result .

Strategies to Improve CTR

Alex Jackson, Paid Media Team Lead at Hallam Internet, stresses the value of a structured approach:

"When A/B testing, you should pretend you’re back in high school science. Approach it like an experiment. You need to have a hypothesis to start with. And you need to be methodical by only changing one variable at a time. Figure out what you think might make your ad more successful, and tweak that while keeping everything else the same."

This experimental mindset has helped companies achieve impressive results:

Underoutfit increased CTR by 47% by combining branded content ads with standard Facebook ads .
A company boosted CTR by 162% simply by changing their CTA from "Request a quote" to "Request pricing" .
Facebook ad tests showed that images directly tied to the content performed 75% better than alternative visuals .

These examples highlight the importance of refining specific elements to improve performance.

Best Practices for CTR Testing

To get the most out of your A/B tests, focus on areas that directly influence user engagement :

Place clickable elements strategically: Position them where users naturally focus their attention.
Craft clear, action-driven CTAs: Use direct, engaging language that connects with your audience.
Create a strong visual hierarchy: Use bold colors and striking images to draw attention to key elements.
Continuously refine messaging: Test and adjust your content to address user needs more effectively.

3. Bounce Rate

Bounce rate refers to the percentage of visitors who land on your website and leave after viewing just one page without taking any further action. In A/B testing, this metric helps gauge how well your content resonates with users and how engaged they are.

Understanding Bounce Rate Benchmarks

Bounce rates can differ based on industry and the type of device used. Here’s a quick look at average bounce rates by device:

Device Type	Average Bounce Rate
Desktop	43%
Mobile	51%
Tablet	45%

For most websites, a bounce rate between 26% and 40% is considered healthy, while rates above 70% might signal a problem that needs immediate attention . E-commerce sites typically aim for bounce rates in the 20%-45% range .

Impact on A/B Testing Results

High bounce rates can skew the results of your A/B tests, making it harder to draw accurate conclusions. According to Jeffrey Vocell, Director of Product Marketing at Iterable:

"Matching keyword intent to your content is important to ensure organic visitors get the content they expect."

If your content doesn’t align with what visitors are looking for, it can lead to higher bounce rates and unreliable test results.

Real-World Testing Example

A real-world example shows how bounce rates can drive design decisions. Removing publication dates on a website dropped the bounce rate from 84% to 72% over six weeks. However, reintroducing those dates raised the rate back to 76%, ultimately leading to a design change .

Key Optimization Strategies

To lower bounce rates and improve user engagement, consider these strategies:

Improve Page Speed: Compress images and enable browser caching to reduce load times .
Optimize for Mobile: Use responsive design and simplify navigation for mobile users .
Make Content Relevant: Ensure your content matches user search intent and clearly communicates its value.
Enhance User Experience: Eliminate intrusive elements like full-screen pop-ups .

Keep in mind, not all high bounce rates are bad. For example, blog posts often have higher bounce rates, which doesn’t necessarily mean they’re underperforming .

Exit Rate vs. Bounce Rate

While every bounce counts as an exit, not every exit is a bounce . For context, a 2022 survey of 3,244 Shopify sites revealed that desktop visitors from Google searches had an average bounce rate of 41.1%. This serves as a useful benchmark for evaluating your campaigns .

4. Time on Page

Time on page tracks how long users stay on a single page, giving a direct view of how they interact with your content. It’s a helpful metric to pair with conversion and engagement rates for a deeper understanding of user behavior.

Time on Page vs. Session Duration

Here’s how these metrics differ:

Time on Page: Measures how long a user spends on one specific page.
Session Duration: Tracks the total time spent across multiple pages in a single visit.
Scroll Depth: Shows how much of a page a user views.

Making Sense of the Data

To get a clearer picture, combine time on page with scroll depth and session duration. For example, a high scroll depth with a short session could mean users are skimming through your content. On the other hand, a low scroll depth paired with a long session might show they’re focusing on specific sections .

Why It Matters for Conversions

Time on site can directly impact conversions. As Greg Brown, an optimization expert, explains:

"The longer someone remains on your site, the more likely they are to convert on an offer or display some other trackable form of purchase intent."

How to Improve Time on Page

Here are a few ways to keep users engaged:

Better Content: Create well-structured, visually appealing content that holds attention.
Technical Fixes: Optimize for mobile, speed up page loads, and ensure smooth navigation.
Enhanced User Experience: Personalize content, suggest related articles, and use clear navigation elements.

Spotting Patterns in User Behavior

If users spend little time on a page and bounce, it might mean the content doesn’t match their intent. On the flip side, extended time without conversions could point to unclear calls-to-action (CTAs). You might also notice differences in how users engage on mobile versus desktop, which could signal platform-specific issues.

5. Revenue per Visit

Revenue per Visit (RPV) is a metric that shows how much revenue your site earns per visitor. It combines transaction rates with average order values, giving you a clearer picture of performance.

How to Calculate RPV

To calculate RPV, divide your total revenue by the number of visitors within a specific time frame. For instance, if your site earns $10,000 from 2,000 visitors, your RPV is $5 per visitor . Since RPV data often doesn’t follow a normal distribution, it’s better to use the Wilcoxon Rank Sum Test instead of traditional T-tests to check for statistical significance .

RPV in Action

Take the case of VeggieTales, which improved their RPV through targeted optimizations:

38% year-over-year RPV growth
17.4% revenue increase on category pages
13.9% revenue boost on product pages
14.3% higher RPV on checkout pages
36.8% RPV growth on the homepage

These numbers show how impactful RPV optimization can be, though it’s normal for RPV to fluctuate.

Why RPV Might Fluctuate

A drop in RPV isn’t always a red flag. Here are two examples:

Scenario	Impact on RPV	Possible Upside
More visitors (e.g., 20,000 vs. 15,000)	Falls from $3.35 to $2.50	Reaching a broader audience
Stock issues affecting products	Falls from $3.35 to $2.50	Maintains traffic despite challenges

These changes might reflect growth opportunities rather than problems.

How to Improve RPV

You can use A/B testing to explore ways to increase RPV. Some effective strategies include:

Simplifying the user experience and checkout process
Trying out different product images or layouts
Testing price points and shipping costs
Adding product bundles or personalized recommendations

"Revenue per visitor is that composite metric, which accounts for both transaction rate and AOV."

sbb-itb-f16ed34

6. Average Order Value

Average Order Value (AOV) is a metric that shows how much customers typically spend in a single transaction. It’s a key figure for assessing A/B tests because it helps you understand if changes to your website are influencing customer spending habits.

How to Calculate and Monitor AOV

To figure out your AOV, simply divide your total revenue by the number of orders during a specific time period . Many businesses use a monthly moving average to keep track of this metric . Monitoring AOV is critical for determining how A/B tests affect customer spending.

Metric Component	Formula Element
Total Revenue	Total sales amount
Number of Orders	Total transactions
Time Period	Typically monthly
Statistical Significance	Needed for reliable results

Real-World Examples of AOV Changes

A/B testing often leads to measurable increases in AOV. For instance, Swanky, a Shopify CRO agency, ran tests in January 2022 that made a big impact. By adjusting a dynamic banner, mobile AOV rose by 10.16%, desktop/tablet AOV grew by 9.64%, orders under $30 dropped by 22.41%, and orders in the $50–$70 range doubled.

Strategies That Have Worked

Some businesses have seen impressive AOV growth through targeted A/B testing:

Paperstone, an office supplies company, boosted its AOV by 18.94% after testing bulk discount options, which also increased revenue by 16.8% .
BEAR, a retailer, saw a 16% revenue jump by refining its cross-selling approach .

"Sometimes marketers focus much of their energy on increasing traffic to a website when it would be more impactful and profitable to increase their AOV. Increasing traffic typically costs money, while increasing AOV does not." – Optimizely

Ideas for A/B Testing to Improve AOV

If you’re looking to improve AOV, try these testing approaches:

Experiment with free shipping thresholds that are slightly higher than your current AOV.
Test volume discounts or bulk pricing deals.
Adjust upselling placements during the checkout process.
Try bundling products together in new combinations.
Use dynamic pricing tailored to different customer segments.

Since nearly 70% of shopping carts are abandoned , it’s crucial to experiment with strategies that encourage larger purchases without discouraging customers from completing their transactions.

7. Customer Lifetime Value (CLV)

CLV helps measure the long-term benefits of A/B testing by estimating the total revenue a customer generates over their lifetime. It provides a broader perspective, going beyond short-term metrics like conversion rates and bounce rates.

Understanding CLV in the Context of A/B Testing

The formula for CLV is:

CLV = Average Transaction Size × Number of Transactions × Retention Period

This metric is crucial for identifying changes that deliver sustained growth rather than short-lived performance boosts.

CLV Component	Relevance to A/B Testing
Transaction Size	Tests involving pricing strategies, upsells, and cross-sells
Transaction Frequency	Tests aimed at boosting engagement and repeat purchases
Retention Period	Tests that improve customer experience and loyalty
Support Quality	Tests focused on optimizing customer service interactions

Common A/B Testing Mistakes That Impact CLV

For example, an A/B test offering a 20% discount increased conversions by 25%, but profits dropped as customers waited for discounts to shop again .

Strategies to Improve CLV Through Testing

Customer Experience Testing
A SaaS company simplified its onboarding process, increasing sign-ups by 18%. However, churn rates rose because users skipped key customization steps .
Value Proposition Optimization
Experiment with different messaging and offers, but keep an eye on retention. A typical benchmark for Lifetime Value to Customer Acquisition Cost is 3:1 .

"The quality of engagement impacts customer acquisition as well as LTV. To extract the maximum value from acquired customers, all interfaces with customers should be tested and refined."
– Cro Metrics

Monitoring Long-Term Impact

It’s essential to look beyond immediate results and focus on long-term customer behavior:

Track metrics after the test to evaluate lasting effects
Use predictive models to estimate future behavior
Monitor customer satisfaction and loyalty trends
Segment customers to understand how different groups are affected

Research shows that a 5% boost in retention can lead to a 25% or higher increase in profits . This highlights the importance of prioritizing lasting relationships over short-term gains.

Best Practices for CLV-Centered Testing

Use holdout groups to measure the effects after implementation
Watch for secondary impacts, like increased support ticket volume
Collect customer reviews and feedback
Study engagement trends across different customer segments
Regularly update CLV estimates with fresh data

Additionally, 93% of customers are more likely to make repeat purchases if they receive excellent customer service . This statistic reinforces the value of refining customer touchpoints through testing.

8. Form Completion Rate

Form completion rate is a key metric for understanding user engagement. It measures the percentage of users who complete and submit a form after starting it. This metric is especially useful after analyzing revenue and order-based performance indicators.

Understanding Form Completion Metrics

Data shows that 44.96% of users who view a form complete it, while 65.99% of users who begin filling out a form finish the process .

How Form Design Affects Completion Rates

Studies have found that multi-step forms – featuring one question per step – perform 86% better than traditional single-page forms with multiple questions . This challenges the idea that shorter forms are always more effective.

Form Element	Testing Approach	Potential Impact
Field Count	Remove non-essential fields	Can boost or hurt conversions, depending on context
Form Structure	Use multi-step designs	Up to 86% higher conversion rates
Validation	Test inline vs. post-submission	Reduces frustration and abandonment
Progress Indicators	Add subtle progress indicators	Motivates users to complete the form
Field Order	Experiment with field sequences	Can heavily influence completion rates

Case Studies in Form Optimization

Unbounce experimented with reducing form fields, which initially dropped conversions by 14%. However, adding back fields users valued and improving labels boosted conversions by 19.21% .

"I removed all the fields that people actually want to interact with and only left the crappy ones they don’t want to interact with. Kinda stupid." – Michael Aagaard, ConversionXL

Another test by MarketingExperiments compared forms with varying field counts:

11-field form (control)
15-field form: 109% increase in conversions
10-field form: 87% increase in conversions

When these results were applied to their membership form, conversions jumped by an impressive 226% .

Strategies for Recovering Abandoned Forms

Re-engagement emails can be surprisingly effective. Up to 19% of users return to complete a form after receiving a follow-up email . This underscores the value of tracking form abandonment and implementing recovery efforts.

Advanced Testing Considerations

Here are some additional elements to test for better form performance:

Timing of field validation
Privacy messaging clarity
Button text and calls-to-action
Placement of the form on the page
Integration with payment systems

A great example comes from Venture Harbour. They redesigned a 30-question form into a four-step process for WhatIsMyComfortZone.com. The result? A 53% conversion rate .

These strategies highlight how thoughtful testing and design can transform user interactions with forms.

9. Page Load Speed

Page load speed has a direct impact on A/B testing outcomes. Even a one-second delay in loading can lead to a 7% drop in conversions and an 11% decrease in page views .

Impact on Test Results

Page speed and A/B testing are closely linked, as the tools used for testing can affect load times. Different platforms influence site performance in varying ways:

Testing Platform	Load Time (LCP)	Start Time To Variant	Size (uncompressed)
Howuku Optimize	560ms	432ms	15.3kb
Google Optimize	569ms	396ms	131kb
VWO	725ms	587ms	254kb++
CrazyEgg	810ms	698ms	128kb++
FigPii	2200ms	2052ms	446kb++

Real-World Performance Impact

The effects of slow page load times are well-documented:

Amazon: A delay of just 100ms resulted in a 1% drop in sales .
Google: Slower search results (by 400ms) led to 8 million fewer daily searches .
Vodafone: By improving LCP by 31%, they saw a 15% increase in lead-to-visit rate and an 8% boost in sales .

These examples highlight the importance of optimizing page speed across all devices, especially mobile.

Mobile Considerations

Mobile users are particularly affected by slow load times. Mobile pages load 70.9% slower than desktop pages , and 53% of mobile visitors will leave if a page takes more than three seconds to load .

Optimization Strategies

To ensure accurate A/B testing results while minimizing speed-related issues, consider the following:

Script Implementation:
Place test scripts at the top of the <head> tag, use asynchronous loading, and combine data into a single file .
Performance Monitoring:
- Use tools like Google PageSpeed Insights for an initial evaluation .
- Track desktop and mobile performance separately.
- Prioritize optimization on high-intent pages such as checkout and login .

"When variations are presented to users smoothly and without delays, you can reliably provide a seamless experience for users and protect the integrity of your test results." – SiteSpect, Inc.

Speed Impact on Conversion

Page load speed significantly influences conversion rates:

B2B sites loading in 1 second convert 3x more effectively than those taking 5 seconds .
E-commerce sites loading within 1 second convert 2.5x more visitors than those loading in 5 seconds .
Desktop users experience a 21% bounce rate when delays reach 3 seconds .

Since conversion rates are at the heart of A/B testing, maintaining fast load speeds is essential for trustworthy and actionable results.

Understanding how users move through your site can take your A/B testing to the next level. By analyzing navigation patterns, you can uncover insights that help fine-tune your testing and improve overall results.

When studying user navigation during A/B testing, keep an eye on these important metrics:

Metric	What It Measures	Why It Matters
Click-Through Rate	Engagement with specific elements	Highlights how effective navigation and CTAs are
Scroll Depth	How far users scroll	Identifies which sections grab attention and where users lose interest
Abandonment Rate	Unfinished user journeys	Pinpoints obstacles in the conversion process
Average Session Duration	Time spent on the site	Reflects content relevance and visitor engagement

Google Analytics offers several tools to help track and understand user navigation patterns:

Navigation Summary Report
This report shows which pages users visit before and after a specific page, revealing popular paths .
Reverse Goal Path Analysis
Tracks the routes users take to achieve conversion goals, helping you understand what works .
Users Flow Visualization
A visual map of how visitors move through your site, broken down by traffic source or channel .

These tools can help you identify areas to tweak, like page layouts or CTAs, to better align with user behavior.

Strategies for Improvement

To refine your navigation patterns:

Use heatmaps to see where users click most and how they scroll .
Gather direct feedback through user surveys and usability testing .
Experiment with different layouts and CTAs to smooth out the user journey and boost conversions .

Conclusion

Running effective A/B tests requires looking beyond basic metrics. Analyzing multiple data points together helps marketers see how design changes truly affect user behavior and overall business goals.

Why Combine Metrics?

Focusing on just one metric can lead to a narrow perspective. For example, a spike in click-through rate might seem like a win, but pairing it with stats like bounce rate or time on page reveals whether users are genuinely engaging. By looking at metrics as a whole, you can avoid trade-offs that hurt other important areas. This approach gives a clearer picture of performance.

Primary, Secondary, and Guardrail Metrics

Metrics work best when they balance each other out. Here’s how they fit together:

Metric Type	Role	Examples
Primary	Tracks the main test goal	Conversion rate, CTR
Secondary	Adds context to primary data	Time on page, scroll depth
Guardrail	Ensures no harm to overall performance	Revenue per visit, customer satisfaction

This system ensures you’re improving one area without negatively impacting others.

Learning from Test Results

A/B testing is all about learning and refining. Take HubSpot’s example: when they tested different CTA text, adding descriptive language alongside "free" boosted results by 4%. Small adjustments like this highlight the value of experimenting and fine-tuning for better outcomes.

Keeping Optimization Forward-Thinking

To get the most out of A/B testing:

Align metrics with your business goals
Use insights from one test to shape the next
Combine hard data with user feedback
Keep an eye on the bigger picture with balanced metrics

The real strength of these metrics lies in how they work together. By taking a well-rounded approach, marketers can create better user experiences while driving meaningful business results.